Sphere Packing in Lean

8 Proof of Theorem 5.3

Our proof of the Theorem 5.3 relies on the following two inequalities for modular objects.

Proposition 8.1
✓
#

Consider the function \(A:(0,\infty )\to \mathbb {C}\) defined as

\begin{equation} \label{eqn:defA} A(t):=-t^2\phi _0(i/t)-\frac{36}{\pi ^2}\, \psi _I(it). \end{equation}
205

Then

\begin{equation} \label{eqn:ineqA} A(t) {\lt} 0 \end{equation}
206

for all \(t {\gt} 0\).

Proposition 8.2
✓
#

Consider the function \(B:(0,\infty )\to \mathbb {C}\) defined as

\begin{equation} \label{eqn:defB} B(t) := -t^2\phi _0(i/t)+\frac{36}{\pi ^2}\, \psi _I(it) \end{equation}
207

Then

\begin{equation} \label{eqn:ineqB} B(t) {\gt} 0 \end{equation}
208

for all \(t {\gt} 0\).

Here we formalize the proof of the inequalities by Lee [ 6 ] . First, we can rewrite the inequality in 8.1 as follows.

Definition 8.3
✓
#

Define two (quasi) modular forms as

\begin{align} F(z) & = (E_2(z) E_4(z) - E_6(z))^2 \label{eqn:defF} \\ G(z) & = H_2(z)^{3} (2 H_{2}(z)^{2} + 5 H_{2}(z) H_{4}(z) + 5 H_{4}(z)^{2}). \label{eqn:defG} \end{align}

We have

\begin{align} \phi _0 & = \frac{F}{\Delta } \label{eqn:phi0-F} \\ \psi _S & = -\frac{1}{2} \frac{G}{\Delta }\label{eqn:psiS-G} \end{align}
Proof ▶

211 is clear from the definitions. 212 is already shown in Lemma 7.19.

Inequality 206 and 208 are equivalent to

\begin{align} F(it) + \frac{18}{\pi ^2} G(it) {\gt} 0 \label{eqn:ineqAnew} \\ F(it) - \frac{18}{\pi ^2} G(it) {\lt} 0 \label{eqn:ineqBnew} \end{align}

respectively.

Proof ▶

By 165,

\begin{equation} \psi _I(it) = (\psi _S|_{-2}S)(it) = (it)^{2}\psi _S\left(-\frac{1}{it}\right) = -t^2 \psi _S\left(\frac{i}{t}\right). \end{equation}
215

Combined with Lemma 8.4 we can rewrite 206 as

\begin{equation} A(t) = -t^2 \phi _0\left(\frac{i}{t}\right) + \frac{36}{\pi ^2} \psi _S\left(\frac{i}{t}\right) {\lt} 0 \Leftrightarrow \frac{F(it)}{\Delta (it)} + \frac{18}{\pi ^2} \frac{G(it)}{\Delta (it)} {\gt} 0 \end{equation}
216

for \(t {\gt} 0\), which is equivalent to 213 by Corollary 6.25. Equivalences of 208 and 214 follows similarly; just change the sign.

Now, the first inequality 213 follows from the positivity of each \(F(it)\) and \(G(it)\).

Lemma 8.6
✓

For all \(t {\gt} 0\), we have \(F(it) {\gt} 0\) and \(G(it) {\gt} 0\).

Proof ▶

By Ramanujan’s identity 80, we have \(F(z) = 9 E_4'(z)^2\) and

\begin{equation} F(it) = 9E_4'(it)^2 = 9 \left(240\sum _{n \geq 1} n \sigma _3(n) e^{-2 \pi n t} \right)^{2} {\gt} 0. \end{equation}
217

\(G(it) {\gt} 0\) follows from positivity of \(H_2(it)\) and \(H_4(it)\) (Lemma 6.42).

Corollary 8.7
✓
#

213 holds.

Proof ▶

This directly follows from Lemma 8.6.

To prove the second inequality 214, we need some identities satisfied by \(F\) and \(G\).

Lemma 8.8
✓

\(F\) and \(G\) satisfy the following differential equations:

\begin{align} \partial _{12}\partial _{10} F - \frac{5}{6} E_{4} F & = 7200 \Delta (-E_{2}’) \label{eqn:ddf} \\ \partial _{12}\partial _{10} G - \frac{5}{6} E_{4} G & = -640 \Delta H_{2} \label{eqn:ddg} \end{align}
Proof ▶

Both can be shown by direct computations. By Ramanujan’s identities (Theorem 6.49) and the product rule of Serre derivatives (Theorem 6.52), we have

\begin{align} \partial _{5} (E_2 E_4 - E_6) & = (E_2 E_4 - E_6)’ - \frac{5}{12} E_2 (E_2 E_4 - E_6) \\ & = \frac{E_2^2 - E_4}{12} \cdot E_4 + E_2 \cdot \frac{E_2 E_4 - E_6}{3} - \frac{E_2 E_6 - E_4^2}{2} - \frac{5}{12}E_2 (E_2 E_4 - E_6) \\ & = -\frac{5}{12} (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2) \label{eqn:S5} \\ \partial _{7} (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2) & = (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2)’ - \frac{7}{12} E_2 (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2) \\ & = \frac{E_2^2 - E_4}{12} \cdot E_6 + E_2 \cdot \frac{E_2 E_6 - E_4^2}{2} - 2 E_4 \cdot \frac{E_2 E_4 - E_6}{3} - \frac{7}{12} E_2 (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2) \\ & = -\frac{7}{12} E_4 (E_2 E_4 - E_6) \label{eqn:S7} \end{align}

and using these we can compute

\begin{align} \partial _{10} F & = \partial _{10} (E_2 E_4 - E_6)^2 \\ & = 2 (E_2 E_4 - E_6) \partial _{5} (E_2 E_4 - E_6) \\ & = -\frac{5}{6} (E_2 E_4 - E_6) (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2), \\ \partial _{12}\partial _{10} F & = -\frac{5}{6} \partial _{12} ((E_2 E_4 - E_6) (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2)) \\ & = -\frac{5}{6} (\partial _{5}(E_2 E_4 - E_6)) (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2) - \frac{5}{6} (E_2 E_4 - E_6) (\partial _{7} (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2)) \\ & = \frac{25}{72} (E_2 E_6 - E_4^2)^2 + \frac{35}{72} E_4 (E_2 E_4 - E_6)^2, \\ \partial _{12}\partial _{10}F - \frac{5}{6} E_4 F & = \frac{25}{72}(E_2 E_6 - E_4^2)^2 + \frac{35}{72} E_4 (E_2 E_4 - E_6)^2 - \frac{5}{6} E_4 (E_2 E_4 - E_6)^2 \\ & = \frac{25}{72} ((E_2 E_6 - E_4^2)^2 - E_4 (E_2 E_4 - E_6)^2) \\ & = \frac{25}{72} (- E_2^2 E_4^3 + E_2^2 E_6^2 + E_4^4 - E_4 E_6^2) \\ & = -\frac{25}{72} (E_4^3 - E_6^2) (E_2^2 - E_4) \\ & = 7200 \cdot \frac{E_4^3 - E_6^2}{1728} \cdot \frac{-E_2^2 + E_4}{12}\\ & = 7200 \Delta (-E_2’) \end{align}

which proves 218. Similarly, 219 can be proved using Proposition 6.51 and Lemma 6.41.

218 (resp. 219) is positive (resp. negative) on the (positive) imaginary axis.

Proof ▶

From 13 and Lemma 6.25,

\begin{equation*} 7200 (-E_2’(it)) \Delta (it) = 7200 \cdot 24 \left(\sum _{n \ge 1} n \sigma _1(n) e^{-2 \pi n t}\right) \cdot \Delta (it) {\gt} 0. \end{equation*}

Negativity of 219, i.e. \(-640 \Delta (it) H_2(it) {\lt} 0\) follows from Corollary 6.42 and 6.25.

The second inequality 214 follows from the following two observations. Since \(G(it) {\gt} 0\) for all \(t {\gt} 0\), we can define the quotient

\begin{equation} \label{eqn:Q} Q(t) := \frac{F(it)}{G(it)} \end{equation}
238

as a function on \((0, \infty )\).

Lemma 8.10
✓
#

We have

\begin{equation} \lim _{t \to 0^+} Q(t) = \frac{18}{\pi ^2}. \end{equation}
239

Proof ▶

We have

\begin{equation} \lim _{t \to 0^+} Q(t) = \lim _{t \to 0^+} \frac{F(it)}{G(it)} = \lim _{t \to \infty } \frac{F(i/t)}{G(i/t)}. \end{equation}
240

By using the transformation laws of Eisenstein series 14, 10 (for \(k = 4, 6\)) and the thetanull functions, 27, 29, we get

\begin{align} F\left(\frac{i}{t}\right) & = t^{12} F(it) - \frac{12t^{11}}{\pi } (E_2(it)E_4(it) - E_6(it))E_4(it) + \frac{36t^{10}}{\pi ^2}E_4(it)^2, \\ G\left(\frac{i}{t}\right) & = t^{10} H_{4}(it)^{3}(2H_{4}(it)^{2} + 5 H_{4}(it)H_{2}(it) + 5 H_{2}(it)^{2}). \end{align}

Since \(F\), \(E_2 E_4 - E_6\) and \(H_2\) are cusp forms, we have \(\lim _{t \to \infty }t^k A(it) = 0\) when \(A(z)\) is one of these forms and \(k \geq 0\). From \(\lim _{t \to \infty } E_4(it) = 1 = \lim _{t \to \infty }H_{4}(it)\), we get

\begin{align} \lim _{t \to \infty } \frac{F(i/t)}{G(i/t)} & = \lim _{t \to \infty } \frac{t^{12} F(it) - \frac{12t^{11}}{\pi } (E_2(it)E_4(it) - E_6(it))E_4(it) + \frac{36t^{10}}{\pi ^2}E_4(it)^2}{t^{10} H_{4}(it)^{3}(2H_{4}(it)^{2} + 5 H_{4}(it)H_{2}(it) + 5 H_{2}(it)^{2})} \\ & = \lim _{t \to \infty } \frac{t^{2} F(it) - \frac{12t}{\pi } (E_2(it)E_4(it) - E_6(it))E_4(it) + \frac{36}{\pi ^2}E_4(it)^2}{H_{4}(it)^{3}(2H_{4}(it)^{2} + 5 H_{4}(it)H_{2}(it) + 5 H_{2}(it)^{2})} \\ & = \frac{18}{\pi ^2}. \end{align}

Let \(F\) be a quasimodular form where the vanishing order of \(F\) at infinity is \(n_0 {\gt} 0\), i.e. \(F(z) = \sum _{n \geq n_0} a_n q^{n}\) with \(a_{n_0} \ne 0\). Then

\begin{equation} \lim _{t \to \infty } \frac{F'(it)}{F(it)} = n_0. \end{equation}
246

Proof ▶

By Lemma 6.44,

\begin{equation} \lim _{t \to \infty } \frac{F'(it)}{F(it)} = \lim _{t \to \infty } \frac{\sum _{n \ge n_0} n a_n e^{-2 \pi n t}}{\sum _{n \ge n_0} a_n e^{-2 \pi n t}} = \lim _{t \to \infty } \frac{n_0 a_{n_0} e^{-2 \pi n_0 t} + O(e^{-2 \pi (n_0 + 1) t})}{a_{n_0} e^{-2 \pi n_0 t} + O(e^{-2 \pi (n_0 + 1) t})} = n_0. \end{equation}
247

Proposition 8.12
✓

The function \(t \mapsto Q(t)\) is strictly decreasing.

Proof ▶

It is enough to show that

\begin{align} \frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t} \left(\frac{F(it)}{G(it)}\right) {\lt} 0 & \Leftrightarrow (- 2\pi ) \frac{F'(it)G(it) - F(it) G'(it)}{G(it)^{2}} {\lt} 0 \\ & \Leftrightarrow F’(it) G(it) - F(it) G’(it) {\gt} 0 \\ & \Leftrightarrow (\partial _{10}F)(it) G(it) - F(it) (\partial _{10}G)(it) {\gt} 0. \end{align}

Let \(\mathcal{L}_{1, 0} := (\partial _{10}F) G - F (\partial _{10} G) = F'G - FG'\). Then

\begin{align} \frac{\mathcal{L}_{1, 0}}{FG} = \frac{F'G - FG'}{FG} = \frac{F'}{F} - \frac{G'}{G} \end{align}

The vanishing order of \(F\) and \(G\) at the infinity are \(2\) and \(\frac{3}{2}\) respectively, so by Lemma 8.11, we have

\begin{align} \lim _{t \to \infty } \frac{\mathcal{L}_{1, 0}(it)}{F(it) G(it)} = \lim _{t \to \infty } \left(\frac{F'(it)}{F(it)} - \frac{G'(it)}{G(it)}\right) = 2 - \frac{3}{2} = \frac{1}{2} {\gt} 0 \end{align}

so \(\mathcal{L}_{1, 0}(it) {\gt} 0\) for sufficiently large \(t\). Its Serre derivative \(\partial _{22} \mathcal{L}_{1, 0}\) is positive by Corollary 8.9:

\begin{align} \partial _{22} \mathcal{L}_{1, 0} = (\partial _{12} \partial _{10} F) G - F (\partial _{12}\partial _{10} G) = \Delta (7200 (-E_{2}’) G + 640 H_2 F) {\gt} 0. \end{align}

Hence \(\mathcal{L}_{1, 0}(it) {\gt} 0\) by Theorem 6.53, and the monotonicity follows.

Corollary 8.13
✓
#

214 holds.

Proof ▶

\begin{equation} \frac{F(it)}{G(it)} = Q(t) {\lt} \lim _{u \to 0^+} Q(u) = \frac{18}{\pi ^2} \end{equation}
254

and by Lemma 8.6, 214 follows.

Finally, we are ready to prove Theorem 5.3.

The function

\[ g(x):=\frac{\pi \, i}{8640}a(x)+\frac{i}{240\pi }\, b(x) \]

satisfies conditions 6–8.

Proof ▶

First, we prove that 6 holds. By Propositions 7.14 and 7.28 we know that for \(r{\gt}\sqrt{2}\)

\begin{equation} \label{eqn:g A} g(r)=\frac{\pi }{2160}\, \sin (\pi r^2/2)^2\, \int \limits _0^\infty A(t)\, e^{-\pi r^2 t}\, dt\end{equation}
255

where

\[ A(t)=-t^2\phi _0(i/t)-\frac{36}{\pi ^2}\, \psi _I(it). \]

from the Proposition 8.1 we know that \(A(t){\lt}0\quad \mbox{for}\; t\in (0,\infty ).\) Therefore identity 255 implies 6.

Next, we prove 7. By Propositions 7.15 and 7.29 we know that for \(r{\gt}0\)

\begin{equation} \label{eqn:g B} \widehat{g}(r)=\frac{\pi }{2160}\, \sin (\pi r^2/2)^2\, \int \limits _0^\infty B(t)\, e^{-\pi r^2 t}\, dt\end{equation}
256

where

\[ B(t)=-t^2\phi _0(i/t)+\frac{36}{\pi ^2}\, \psi _I(it). \]

Finally, the property 8 readily follows from Proposition 7.16 and Proposition 7.30. This finishes the proof of Theorems 8.14 and 5.3.

1

J. Bruinier, Borcherds products on O(2,l) and Chern classes of Heegner divisors, Springer Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1780 (2002)

2

H. Cohn, N. Elkies, New upper bounds on sphere packings I, Annals of Math. 157 (2003) pp. 689–714.

3

F. Diamond, J. Shurman, A First Course in Modular Forms, Springer New York, 2005.

4

D. Hejhal, The Selberg trace formula for \(\mathrm{PSL}(2, \mathbb {R})\), Springer Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1001 (1983)

5

W. Kohnen, A Very Simple Proof of the \(q\)-Product Expansion of the \(\Delta \)-Function, The Ramanujan Journal 10 (2005): 71-73.

6

S. Lee, Algebraic proof of modular form inequalities for optimal sphere packings, arXiv preprint arXiv:2406.14659 (2024).

7

D. Mumford, Tata Lectures on Theta I, Birkhäuser, 1983.

8

H. Petersson, Ueber die Entwicklungskoeffizienten der automorphen Formen, Acta Mathematica, Bd. 58 (1932), pp. 169–215.

9

H. Rademacher and H. S. Zuckerman, On the Fourier coefficients of certain modular forms of positive dimension, Annals of Math. (2) 39 (1938), pp. 433–462.

10

J. Serre, A Course in Arithmetic, Springer New York, 1973.

11

Maryna S. Viazovska, The sphere packing problem in dimension 8 , Pages 991–1015 from Volume 185 (2017), Issue 3.

12

D. Zagier, Elliptic Modular Forms and Their Applications, In: The 1-2-3 of Modular Forms, (K. Ranestad, ed.) Norway, Springer Universitext, 2008.


Ecole Polytechnique Federale de Lausanne
1015 Lausanne
Switzerland
Email address: maryna.viazovska@epfl.ch